With reguards to the Lanier article, I agree that we are approaching a "hive mind" with sites like Wikipedia and aggregators, but I would go further. Lanier mentions that "You can always tell at least a little about the character of the person who made a Myspace page." I would go so far as to suggest that Myspace is almost as hive minded as Wikipedia, though more subversively so. So many MySpace pages are pastiches of previous pages that it's often difficult for one to stand out as being original. As we discussed in class, one of the reasons people have Myspace is to express themselves, and if their essence, their "space," if you will, is comprised of media from someone else, how can they claim to be individuals? (Related note: I deleted my myspace yesterday)
Am I saying that everyone on MySpace is a mindless drone? While in light of the above parenthetical comment I'd like to say a firm "yes," I can't really say that. But consider the typical MySpace page (typical, not all):
1) A song by someone else. A usually popular band singing a song that the user identifies with. How many other spaces have this song? Probably a lot. How is the song obtained? Through a licensing agreement with the artist that allows their work to be promoted to consumers via free advertising.
2) Artwork, usually from another website, film, magazine, etc. I can't tell you how many MySpaces have the same Dolce and Gabana ad as their backgrounds. What does it say about the individual who identifies with a product or an advertisement enough to promote that for free?
3) A layout designed by someone else. There are a whole mess o' fun layouts that EVERYONE uses. They catch the eye, and the user wants his/her space to also catch the eye.
4) "Chain" comments. These are those comments that sound like chain letters written in horrible, raped English; the ones that say someone is sexy, and if they want to stay sexy, they have to pass along the comment to 10 other people. Such comments spread like viruses, and put their recipients in a hive minded like scenario, where the virus must be spread.
There are other factors as well, but you get the idea. Rather than making someone feel more individual, I believe MySpace makes people feel more the same. Such is the problem with networking sites, though; in order to be connected to more people, you have to surrender a bit of yourself.





